 |
|
 |
| Position | Top player | Team ranking | Top prospect | Organizational ranking | Overall ranking |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Catchers | Yogi Berra | 2nd | Tied for 8th | 4th | |
| First Basemen | Bill Skowron | 3rd | Frank Leja | 8th | 9th |
| Second Basemen | Gil McDougald | 1st | Tied for 8th | 4th | |
| Third Basemen | Pinky May | 7th | Kal Segrist | 5th | 7th |
| Shortstops | Phil Rizzuto | 8th | Tied for 8th | 12th | |
| Left Fielders | Joe DiMaggio | 2nd | Tied for 9th | 7th | |
| Center Fielders | Mickey Mantle | 2nd | Tied for 9th | 3rd | |
| Right Fielders | Jackie Jensen | 5th | Tied for 4th | 7th | |
| Starting Pitchers | Jack Harshman | 4th | Dick Hall | 5th | 4th |
| Relievers | Windy McCall | 4th | Dick Hall | 14th | 13th |
| Closers | Tom Gorman | 13th | Dick Hall | 14th | 15th |
